Best Schools on the Peninsula Near San Mateo: A Homebuyer’s Guide

Casey Sternsmith

For many families, the school question shapes the entire home search. San Mateo offers an unusual range of strong options: sought-after neighborhood elementary schools, specialized choice programs, three well-regarded public high schools, and a deep bench of private schools. Here’s how it works, and what to know before you buy.

At Sternsmith Group, we understand how local knowledge shapes a sound real estate decision. Our work in San Mateo real estate goes beyond property listings. We help buyers understand neighborhood features, school locations, home values, and the details that shape long-term ownership. Here is a closer look at schools near San Mateo and what buyers should know before making a move.

How Public School Assignment Works in San Mateo

San Mateo’s public schools are served by two districts. The San Mateo-Foster City School District covers elementary and middle school, and the San Mateo Union High School District covers grades 9–12.

For elementary school, your home’s address determines your assigned neighborhood school. That makes the attendance boundary one of the most important details in a purchase, and one of the most misunderstood. A home a block from a school isn’t always in its zone. Before you write an offer, we confirm the assigned schools for that exact address with the district.

Top Neighborhood Elementary Schools

Some of San Mateo’s most sought-after neighborhood elementary schools include:

●     Baywood Elementary, serving the Baywood and Aragon neighborhoods

●     Highlands Elementary, serving the San Mateo Highlands

●     George Hall Elementary, serving San Mateo Village & Bay Meadows

Homes within these attendance areas consistently draw strong buyer interest, and that demand is reflected in pricing.

Magnet Programs: Specialized Schools Open to the Whole District

Beyond its neighborhood schools, the San Mateo-Foster City School District offers a set of magnet schools, each built around a specific theme. They follow the same state standards as every other school in the district, but each adds a focus such as language immersion or Montessori learning. The district describes the program as nationally recognized and award-winning.

Language immersion

●     College Park Elementary (K–5): Mandarin immersion. Students can continue at Bayside Academy (6–8).

●     Fiesta Gardens International School (TK–7, adding 8th grade in 2026–27): Spanish immersion, with students continuing through middle school. Abbott Middle School is hosting the program’s upper grades during the transition.

Montessori

●     North Shoreview Montessori (TK–8)

●     Parkside Montessori (TK–8)

How Enrollment Works

District-wide magnet schools have no assigned attendance area, so every student attends by transfer request. Families new to the district first register at the neighborhood school assigned to their address, then request a transfer to the magnet program. Space is limited, so a seat isn’t guaranteed.

What this means for buyers: Students who live in a magnet school’s historic attendance area and are entering TK or kindergarten get neighborhood priority on their transfer request. For families set on a specific program, a home within that historic area can make a real difference, and that’s something we check before you write an offer.

You can look up the assigned school for any address with the district’s school locator. Full program details are on the district’s magnet schools page.

San Mateo’s Public High Schools

●     Aragon High School: One of the top-rated public high schools in California, known for its academic strength and arts programs. The campus sits in the Foothill Terrace neighborhood on the Hillsborough border.

●     San Mateo High School: The city’s oldest high school, opened in 1902, with a long tradition and a campus near downtown.

●     Hillsdale High School: Known for its close-knit learning environment and smaller class sizes, and for a theater tradition that gave rise to Broadway by the Bay.

Private Schools in and Around San Mateo

San Mateo and its neighbors offer a wide range of independent and parochial schools:

●     The Carey School: a private elementary school in San Mateo

●     Crystal Springs Uplands School: an independent middle and high school in Hillsborough

●     The Nueva School: known for gifted education and project-based learning, with campuses in Hillsborough and San Mateo

●     Episcopal Day School of St. Matthew: an independent elementary school in San Mateo

●     Catholic elementary schools: a strong network that includes St. Gregory and St. Matthew

Admissions, tuition, and timelines vary widely, so families considering private school should plan early, often a year or more before enrollment.

How We Help Families Weigh Schools and Homes

Schools are one part of a larger decision. All of our agents are local Mom’s.  We know firsthand what families weigh: the drop-off routes, the after-school activities, the parks, and how a neighborhood feels day to day. When you buy with the Sternsmith Group, we:

●     Confirm school assignments for the exact address before you write an offer

●     Explain how school boundaries affect value and resale in each neighborhood

●     Compare homes on the full picture: school, commute, lot, layout, and price

●     Plan around your timeline, including lottery and private school application dates

Find the Right Home for Your Family

Whether you’re buying your first home, moving up to more space, or relocating to the Peninsula, we’ll help you find a home in the right neighborhood for your family. Call Casey, Tess, and the Sternsmith Group at (650) 678-5455 or visit sternsmith.com to start the conversation. Explore the best Peninsula schools near San Mateo while making a well-informed property choice. Contact our team today to discuss your goals and discover the possibilities across the Peninsula.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which public school districts serve San Mateo?

The San Mateo-Foster City School District serves students from TK through 8th grade, and the San Mateo Union High School District serves grades 9 through 12. Your assigned schools depend on your home’s exact address.

How do I find out which schools serve a specific home?

Enter the address in the San Mateo-Foster City School District’s online school locator. Because boundaries can change, we also confirm the assignment with the district before you write an offer.

Does living near a school guarantee my child can attend?

No. Public school assignment follows attendance boundaries, not distance, so a home a block from a school may be zoned for a different one. Private schools set their own admissions.

What are San Mateo’s magnet schools, and how do I apply?

The district offers magnet programs in Mandarin immersion (College Park and Bayside Academy), Spanish immersion (Fiesta Gardens), and Montessori (North Shoreview and Parkside). There’s no attendance area for these schools. Families register at their assigned neighborhood school, then request a transfer. Space is limited.

Can where I buy improve my chances at a magnet school?

It can. Students who live in a magnet school’s historic attendance area and are entering TK or kindergarten receive neighborhood priority on their transfer request. If a specific program matters to your family, we’ll check whether a home falls within that area.

What are San Mateo’s public high schools?

San Mateo is served by Aragon High School, San Mateo High School, and Hillsdale High School, all part of the San Mateo Union High School District. Your assigned high school depends on your address.

What private schools are near San Mateo?

Options include The Carey School, the Episcopal Day School of St. Matthew, The Nueva School, Crystal Springs Uplands School, and several Catholic elementary schools, including St. Gregory and St. Matthew. Most require applying a year or more ahead, so start early.

Do school boundaries affect home values?

Yes. Homes in the attendance areas of sought-after schools often draw more buyers and stronger prices, and they tend to hold their value well. We’ll show you how school assignment affects pricing in each neighborhood you’re considering.

How does the Sternsmith Group help families choose the right home?

We can help you confirm school assignments for each address, explain how boundaries and magnet priority affect your options, and compare homes on everything that matters: schools, commute, lot, layout, and price.

Is there a Spanish immersion school in San Mateo?

Yes. Fiesta Gardens International School offers a Spanish-English immersion program through the San Mateo-Foster City School District. It currently serves TK through 7th grade and is adding 8th grade in 2026–27, so students can continue immersion through middle school. Abbott Middle School is hosting the program’s upper grades during the transition. As a district-wide magnet school, Fiesta Gardens has no attendance area. Families register at their assigned neighborhood school and then request a transfer, with neighborhood priority for TK and kindergarten students who live in the school’s historic attendance area.

Is there a Mandarin Chinese immersion school in San Mateo?

Yes. College Park Elementary offers a Mandarin Chinese immersion program for kindergarten through 5th grade. Students can continue in Mandarin immersion for grades 6 through 8 at Bayside Academy. Like other magnet schools, College Park has no attendance area. Families request a transfer after registering at their assigned school, and students entering TK or kindergarten who live in its historic attendance area receive neighborhood priority.

Casey Sternsmith

Casey Sternsmith

Founder

Get to Know Me

Meet Casey Sternsmith, founding partner of the Sternsmith Group. In business, exceptional service is what matters most to Casey Sternsmith.

With Casey at the helm of the Sternsmith Group, this level of commitment is shared by all members of the group who pride themselves on being excellent listeners with unwavering integrity, and for providing the best advocacy and negotiation skills for their buyers and sellers.

Casey’s philosophy of “love what you do, or do something else” is at the forefront of the entire team, which is evident by their true passion for helping clients achieve their real estate goals.
 
As a leader in real estate marketing, Casey employs tried and true traditional marketing as well as cutting-edge strategies such as social media marketing and professional videos for every home – from small condos to luxury estate properties. Casey’s clients also benefit from her vast personal network as a lifelong resident of the area.
 
As a result, she often achieves unprecedented outcomes for her sellers with quick sales and prices exceeding the list prices. To her buyers, Casey is known for excelling in competitive multiple-offer situations.
 
With more than 10 years of results that speak for themselves, Casey never looks at the process as a transaction, but rather as a personal decision and life choice that impact each and every day of their life. Because of this, a great deal of Casey’s personal business, and the Sternsmith Group’s as a whole, comes from repeat businesses and referrals.
 
Prior to her career in real estate, Casey owned and operated a personal training/Pilates studio in San Mateo where she honed her customer service, management, organization, and marketing skills. Combined with a bachelor’s degree from UC Santa Barbara, all of this proved to be the ideal foundation for her future success in real estate. Casey and her husband have two small children and reside in Hillsborough.
 
Tess Salter smiling in a navy sleeveless dress against a light background.

Tess Salter

REALTOR®

Get to Know Me

Tess Salter is a top-ranked real estate agent in San Mateo County and a key leader of the Sternsmith Group, known for her exceptional negotiation skills, client-first approach, and record of delivering outstanding results. Tess has helped clients buy and sell homes across San Mateo, Burlingame, Hillsborough, Belmont, San Carlos, Redwood Shores, Redwood City, San Bruno, Millbrae, South San Francisco, Bay Meadows, Menlo Park, and Foster City. She specializes in single-family homes, condominiums, townhomes, luxury estates, and investment properties.

With over 10 years of experience, Tess has sold 71 homes in San Mateo County in 2025 and helped 61 buyers and sellers achieve over $125M in sales in 2024, according to RealTrends. Since 2015, Tess and her partner Casey Sternsmith have closed $1.3B+ in total sales, ranking them among the top 5 agents in San Mateo County and the #1 agents in San Mateo for seven consecutive years.

Tess was recognized by Gentry Magazine as one of the Top 10 Agents Under 40 in 2020, and the Sternsmith Group has been nationally recognized on The Leading 100 for the past seven years, celebrating the top-performing real estate teams in the San Francisco Peninsula.

Tess is known for her expertise in off-market listings, pre-market preparation, luxury marketing strategies, and customized property-specific marketing. She leverages Compass’ advanced technology, social media, and Facebook/Instagram Live tours to maximize exposure and deliver top results. With a strong foundation in finance, accounting, and economics, Tess provides data-driven insights that help clients make strategic real estate decisions.

Outside of real estate, Tess is deeply committed to her community. She served as PARCA Auxiliary President (2024–2025), continues on the PARCA Board (2019–2025), volunteers in Hillsborough schools, served on the West Elementary School Site Council, and chairs the Relay for Life for the American Cancer Society.

With 150+ five-star reviews and a reputation for integrity, responsiveness, and personalized service, Tess Salter and the Sternsmith Group provide exceptional guidance, strategic marketing, and unparalleled support for anyone buying or selling in San Mateo County, Burlingame, Hillsborough, and surrounding Peninsula neighborhoods.

About Us

Get to Know Our Team

Get to know our team of real estate experts.

No result found

WORK WITH US

Insightful local knowledge and extensive expertise. We looks forward to earning your family’s trust and leveraging our success for your benefit for generations to come. We looks forward to earning your family’s trust and leveraging our success for your benefit for generations to come.

Contact Us

Follow Us on Instagram