Choosing an agent shapes everything that follows: the homes you see, the price you pay or receive, and how smoothly the process goes. Rankings can narrow your list. What sets a great San Mateo real estate agent apart is knowing the streets, the buyers, and the details a data tool will never show you. Here’s a closer look at Casey Sternsmith, the team she built, and how they work with buyers and sellers across the Peninsula.
Meet Casey Sternsmith: The Local Leader Behind the Team
Casey founded the Sternsmith Group on a simple belief, captured in her tagline: “Your realtor matters. Experience the difference.” Her knowledge of the Peninsula goes well beyond the houses. She married her high school sweetheart, Benjamin, and as a mom of two, she knows what families weigh when choosing a neighborhood: the schools, the parks, the after-school activities, and which streets are easy for kids to bike. She spends her free time hiking local trails and playing tennis, so she knows the open spaces and community spots that make each town feel like home. When clients ask what it’s actually like to live somewhere, she can tell them from experience.
Clients describe Casey as direct, genuine, and warm, and they often mention her big laugh. She connects quickly with people, and that matters when you’re making one of the biggest decisions of your life. It matters in negotiations too, where relationships with other agents can help a deal come together. Casey has built an all women team of powerhouse agents over the past twenty plus years.
Her track record:
● #1 real estate agent in San Mateo (FastExpert, 2026)
● #1 in San Mateo by closed sales volume, 2018–2025 (MLSListings)
● RealTrends Verified Top Team, ranked #159 in the U.S. and #57 in California by volume among small teams
● Over $1.3 billion in sales since 2015
These numbers show steady work year after year. Still, every home and market is unique, so we treat each client's goals as the real scoreboard. A trusted San Mateo real estate agent earns that trust one closing at a time.
Why Does Local Expertise Matter So Much?
Data tools can tell you what a home sold for. They can’t tell you why. Casey and the Sternsmith Group know the Peninsula at a level no algorithm can match: which streets command a premium, which lots offer the most privacy and the best light, and which homes have the architecture and setting that discerning buyers seek. That understanding comes from years of walking these neighborhoods, knowing the families who live in them, and watching how buyers respond at each showing.
What that knowledge means for you:
● Precise, street-level pricing. On the Peninsula, value can change from one street to the next. We know where those lines fall and price accordingly.
● An eye for what makes a property exceptional. Views, privacy, sun exposure, lot size, and architectural pedigree all shape value, especially at the upper end of the market. We know how buyers weigh each one.
● Insight into how a home fits your life. We know how each neighborhood connects to Highway 280, Highway 101, and Caltrain, and which settings feel secluded while staying close to everything you need.
● A trusted circle of professionals. Our inspectors, contractors, designers, and stagers have worked on the Peninsula’s finest homes and hold every project to the same standard we do.
What Do Buyers Get with Casey's Team?
Every search begins with a conversation. Casey takes the time to understand how you want to live, what matters most in your next home, and where you’re willing to be flexible. From there, the team builds a focused search around your goals and your budget, then guides you with candid advice and skilled negotiation from the first showing through closing.First-Time Buyers
First-Time Buyers
Buying your first home on the Peninsula is a significant milestone. We walk you through each step, from financing and pre-approval to disclosures, offers, and closing, so you always know what comes next. We help you compare neighborhoods and price points side by side, so you can make your first purchase with confidence.
Move-Up Families
Whether you need room for a growing family, a dedicated home office, or a yard for the dog, we focus your search on neighborhoods with larger lots, flexible floor plans, and strong schools. We coordinate the timing of your sale and purchase, so one move leads smoothly into the next.
Relocating Buyers
Moving to the Peninsula from another state or another country requires a guide you can trust. We tour homes on your behalf by video, share an honest picture of each neighborhood, and keep you informed at every stage, from the first search to the final signature.
Downsizers
The right next home should simplify your life without sacrificing comfort. We look for single-level living, lower maintenance, and easy access to dining, shopping, and the places you visit most.
Luxury Clients
Many of the Peninsula’s finest homes trade with little fanfare. Through our network and Compass, we often hear about exceptional properties off market properties, and we share them with clients as they become available. Private showings and complete discretion are standard at every step.
How Does Casey Prepare and Market Your Home?
Every seller wants the strongest possible result with as little disruption as possible. Casey’s team delivers both through a white-glove approach that handles every detail, from the first walk-through to closing day. The best realtor in San Mateo for your sale is one who knows your street, understands who your buyers are, and builds the entire plan around your goals.
Prep That Pays Off
First impressions shape what buyers are willing to pay. Our white-glove preparation service gets your home ready for market without adding to your workload. We walk through your home with you, recommend the improvements that will make the greatest impact, and coordinate our trusted network of painters, contractors, designers, stagers, and landscapers. We oversee every project from start to finish. The results speak through our before-and-after projects. One family, guided by our team, transformed their longtime Baywood home in just six weeks and drew multiple offers.
Personalized Marketing
Every home has its own character, and its marketing should reflect it. We build a custom campaign around your property and the buyers most likely to value it. That includes professional photography, cinematic video, refined print materials, targeted digital outreach, and direct connections with the agents who represent active Peninsula buyers. When the strategy calls for it, we can give select buyers a private preview before your home goes public. When offers arrive, we negotiate every term with one goal: the strongest possible outcome for you.
Questions to Ask Before You Hire Any Agent
The right agent will answer these questions with specifics, not generalities. Here’s what to ask, and what a strong answer sounds like:
● How well do you know my street and the recent sales nearby?
A strong agent can name comparable sales from memory and explain why each one sold for what it did.
● What’s your plan for pricing and marketing my home?
Look for a clear strategy built around your property and its likely buyers, not a standard package.
● Who will I work with day to day?
You should know exactly who will answer your calls, attend showings, and negotiate on your behalf.
● How do you find homes before they reach the open market?
The best agents have strong relationships with other agents and hear about opportunities early.
● What results can you verify?
Ask for rankings from independent sources such as MLSListings, RealTrends, or FastExpert, along with client references you can call.
Ready to Meet Casey and Her Team?
Whether you’re buying, selling, or both, you deserve an advisor with deep local roots and a record of results. Casey, Tess, and the Sternsmith Group will take the time to understand your goals, give you a candid read on the market, and build a plan around you.
Call (650) 678-5455 or visit sternsmith.com to schedule a private consultation with the best realtor in San Mateo for your next move.
Connect with a San Mateo real estate agent who knows your neighborhood by heart.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is the best realtor in San Mateo?
Casey Sternsmith is ranked the #1 real estate agent in San Mateo by FastExpert, and the Sternsmith Group has ranked #1 in San Mateo by closed sales volume on MLSListings every year from 2018 through 2025. The team is also a RealTrends Verified Top Team, ranked #57 in California and #159 in the U.S. by volume among small teams.
Who is Casey Sternsmith?
Casey Sternsmith is the founder of the Sternsmith Group, a Compass team serving San Mateo, Burlingame, Hillsborough, and the surrounding Peninsula. A Peninsula native with two decades of real estate experience, she leads an all-women team alongside her sister and partner, Tess Salter.
Who will I work with day to day?
Casey and Tess lead every client relationship personally, supported by a dedicated team for showings, transaction coordination, and marketing. You’ll always know who to call, and you’ll always get a prompt, candid answer.
What does your white-glove preparation service include?
We walk through your home, recommend the improvements that will have the greatest impact on price, and coordinate every project with our trusted network of painters, contractors, designers, stagers, and landscapers. We oversee the work from start to finish, so your home goes to market at its best without adding to your workload.
How do you market a luxury home?
Every listing receives a custom campaign built around the property and its most likely buyers: professional photography, cinematic video, refined print materials, targeted digital outreach, and direct connections with the agents representing active Peninsula buyers. When the strategy calls for it, we can offer select buyers a private preview before the home goes public.
Can I see homes before they’re publicly listed?
Sometimes. Through our relationships with other agents and our Compass network, we often hear about exceptional homes before they reach the open market. Share your criteria with us early, so you’re ready when the right property becomes available.
Does the team work with first-time buyers?
Yes. We guide first-time buyers through budgeting, financing, disclosures, offers, and inspections. We explain each step in plain terms and help you compare neighborhoods and price points, so you can buy with confidence.
Do you work with relocating and international buyers?
Yes. We regularly help tech professionals relocating to the Peninsula and buyers moving from overseas. We tour homes on your behalf by video, give you an honest picture of each neighborhood, and keep you informed through every step of the transaction.
Which areas does the team serve?
We serve San Mateo, Burlingame, Hillsborough, San Carlos, Belmont, Redwood City, and nearby Peninsula communities. Our team lives and works locally, so every client gets street-level insight, not just market data.