Top Selling Real Estate Team in San Mateo: 2018–2025 Results

Casey Sternsmith

San Mateo County's real estate market rewards local insight, sound judgment, and a sharp understanding of what buyers value. From charming family homes in San Carlos to grand estates in Hillsborough, every property has its own place in the Peninsula market. Between 2018 and 2025, shifting home prices, buyer demand, and lending conditions shaped how people bought and sold homes.

At Sternsmith Group, we understand the details behind these changes. Our knowledge of Peninsula neighborhoods, property values, and buyer trends guides each client through a major life decision. Our work reflects the standards people expect from the top-selling real estate team in San Mateo 2018-2025.

San Mateo Real Estate: Understanding the 2018–2025 Market

The past eight years brought several shifts to the San Mateo County housing market. Interest rates, housing supply, remote work, and changing buyer needs all shaped home sales. Yet local factors remained central to property values.

Single-family homes across the Peninsula offer a wide range of choices. Buyers find classic ranch homes, mid-century properties, newly built residences, and large custom estates. Each type attracts a different audience and commands attention for different reasons.

A home's value depends on more than its square footage. Lot size, street appeal, natural light, floor plan, renovation quality, and access to local amenities all shape buyer interest. A home near downtown San Mateo has a different appeal from a private estate in Hillsborough.

We study these details before advising clients. Recent sales, active listings, pending transactions, and price trends form part of our market research. This approach gives buyers and sellers a clearer picture of the opportunities within their chosen area.

Why Does Local Knowledge Matter When Buying or Selling?

San Mateo County is a collection of distinct communities, each with its own housing stock and buyer pool. A county-wide median rarely tells you what a specific home is worth.

●     San Mateo: A varied market of classic single-family homes, updated residences, and newer townhomes, with easy access to downtown, Caltrain, and Highways 101 and 92

●     Burlingame: Established neighborhoods, architecturally distinctive homes, and a walkable downtown along Burlingame Avenue

●     Hillsborough: The Peninsula’s premier luxury market, with large lots, custom estates, and exceptional privacy

●     Belmont and San Carlos: A mix of traditional and modernized homes, hillside settings with views, and charming local downtowns

●     Redwood City and Menlo Park: Diverse housing options with close ties to Silicon Valley’s major employers

These differences shape every decision. Two homes of the same size can draw very different interests depending on the street, the lot, and the setting. We know where those lines fall, and that street-level knowledge is a key part of what clients expect from the top real estate team in San Mateo.

What Should Buyers Look for Before Purchasing a Home?

A successful purchase means understanding a home’s value, its true condition, and its cost of ownership, not just how it looks. We guide buyers through five areas:

  1. Financial planning. A clear budget anchors the search. We help you account for pre-approval, down payment, property taxes, insurance, and closing costs, so your price range reflects the full cost of ownership.
  2. Location and lifestyle. Commute, schools, parks, and access to dining and errands all affect both daily life and long-term value. We help you weigh them alongside the home itself.
  3. Property condition. Before you write an offer, Tess reviews the seller disclosures and inspection reports with you line by line, including roof age, permits, foundation, plumbing, and electrical. We flag what’s routine, what needs a closer look, and what should change your price.
  4. Comparable sales. We compare lot size, updates, location, and sale timing, so you know what the home is actually worth, not just what it’s listed for.
  5. Offer strategy. Price is only one part of a winning offer. Deposit, financing, contingencies, and closing date all matter, and we structure each one to compete while protecting your interests.

Every buyer’s path is different. First-time buyers get step-by-step guidance. Move-up families need a plan that coordinates selling and buying. Relocating tech professionals and international buyers need a trusted local guide, and investors need clear market insights and guidance to make informed property decisions.

How Do We Build a Strong Marketing Plan for Sellers?

A strong sale starts with understanding exactly what makes your home valuable and who is most likely to buy it.

●     Pricing strategy: Built on comparable sales, current competition, your home’s condition, and buyer demand in your neighborhood

●     White-glove preparation: We recommend the improvements that will have the greatest impact, then coordinate and oversee our network of painters, contractors, designers, stagers, and landscapers, so you never have to manage a vendor

●     Professional presentation: Photography, cinematic video, floor plans, and refined print materials that show buyers what makes the home exceptional

●     Targeted exposure: Digital outreach and direct connections with the agents representing active Peninsula buyers

●     Offer evaluation: We compare every offer on price, financing, contingencies, deposit, and timing, then negotiate for the strongest overall result

The results show it. Our team’s listings sell in a median of 12 days.

What Role Do Off-Market Opportunities Play in Real Estate?

Not every home reaches the public market at the same time. Some sellers prefer a private approach to selling their home, and some buyers value the chance to see a home with less competition.

These opportunities depend on the seller’s consent and current listing rules. Through our relationships with agents across the Peninsula and our Compass network, we often hear about homes before they’re publicly listed. When one fits a client’s goals, we review its price, condition, disclosures, and terms together.

For sellers, a private launch is a strategic choice with real tradeoffs among privacy, exposure, and timing. We explain each option and help you choose the approach that best serves your goals.

What Sets Sternsmith Group Apart Across Different Price Ranges?

Real estate needs change at every stage of life. First-time buyers often weigh affordability and location. Growing families need bedrooms, outdoor space, and a practical floor plan. Downsizers want a well-designed home with less upkeep. Luxury clients look for architecture, privacy, land, views, and quality of finish.

Our advice reflects those differences. We take time to understand each client’s plans, then connect them with what the market is actually doing. The top real estate team in San Mateo should offer more than a list of homes or a standard sales plan. It should offer sound judgment, candid communication, and a deep understanding of the neighborhoods where you want to live. Our clients say we deliver: the Sternsmith Group has earned more than 235 five-star reviews across Google, Zillow, and Yelp.

Plan Your Next Real Estate Move with Sternsmith Group

Whether you’re buying, selling, relocating, or searching for a luxury home, Casey, Tess, and our team are ready to give you a candid read on the market and a clear plan for your next step. Call (650) 678-5455 or visit sternsmith.com to schedule a private consultation with the top real estate team in San Mateo.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which areas does the Sternsmith Group serve?

We serve San Mateo County and the broader Peninsula, including San Mateo, Burlingame, Hillsborough, Belmont, San Carlos, Redwood City, and Menlo Park.

Is the Sternsmith Group the top real estate team in San Mateo?

The Sternsmith Group ranked #1 in San Mateo by closed sales volume on MLSListings every year from 2018 through 2025. Founder Casey Sternsmith is also ranked the #1 real estate agent in San Mateo by FastExpert, and the team is a RealTrends Verified Top Team.

Do you represent first-time homebuyers?

Yes. We guide first-time buyers through the search, financing, comparable sales, disclosures, offers, and escrow, so each step is clear and each decision is well informed.

How do you prepare a home for sale?

Our white-glove preparation service handles everything. We recommend the improvements that will matter most to buyers, then coordinate and oversee every project, from painting and repairs to staging and landscaping.

How do buyers find homes before they’re publicly listed?

Through relationships with local agents, buyers can sometimes learn about homes before they reach the open market. Availability depends on the seller’s consent and current listing rules. We share these opportunities with clients when they fit their goals.

How do you determine a home’s market value?

We study recent comparable sales, active and pending listings, the home’s features, lot size, and condition, and current buyer demand in the neighborhood. That research becomes a pricing strategy grounded in current market evidence.

Rankings sources: FastExpert (2026); MLSListings closed sales volume, San Mateo, 2018–2025; RealTrends Verified, latest reporting cycle.

Casey Sternsmith

Casey Sternsmith

Founder

Get to Know Me

Meet Casey Sternsmith, founding partner of the Sternsmith Group. In business, exceptional service is what matters most to Casey Sternsmith.

With Casey at the helm of the Sternsmith Group, this level of commitment is shared by all members of the group who pride themselves on being excellent listeners with unwavering integrity, and for providing the best advocacy and negotiation skills for their buyers and sellers.

Casey’s philosophy of “love what you do, or do something else” is at the forefront of the entire team, which is evident by their true passion for helping clients achieve their real estate goals.
 
As a leader in real estate marketing, Casey employs tried and true traditional marketing as well as cutting-edge strategies such as social media marketing and professional videos for every home – from small condos to luxury estate properties. Casey’s clients also benefit from her vast personal network as a lifelong resident of the area.
 
As a result, she often achieves unprecedented outcomes for her sellers with quick sales and prices exceeding the list prices. To her buyers, Casey is known for excelling in competitive multiple-offer situations.
 
With more than 10 years of results that speak for themselves, Casey never looks at the process as a transaction, but rather as a personal decision and life choice that impact each and every day of their life. Because of this, a great deal of Casey’s personal business, and the Sternsmith Group’s as a whole, comes from repeat businesses and referrals.
 
Prior to her career in real estate, Casey owned and operated a personal training/Pilates studio in San Mateo where she honed her customer service, management, organization, and marketing skills. Combined with a bachelor’s degree from UC Santa Barbara, all of this proved to be the ideal foundation for her future success in real estate. Casey and her husband have two small children and reside in Hillsborough.
 
Tess Salter smiling in a navy sleeveless dress against a light background.

Tess Salter

REALTOR®

Get to Know Me

Tess Salter is a top-ranked real estate agent in San Mateo County and a key leader of the Sternsmith Group, known for her exceptional negotiation skills, client-first approach, and record of delivering outstanding results. Tess has helped clients buy and sell homes across San Mateo, Burlingame, Hillsborough, Belmont, San Carlos, Redwood Shores, Redwood City, San Bruno, Millbrae, South San Francisco, Bay Meadows, Menlo Park, and Foster City. She specializes in single-family homes, condominiums, townhomes, luxury estates, and investment properties.

With over 10 years of experience, Tess has sold 71 homes in San Mateo County in 2025 and helped 61 buyers and sellers achieve over $125M in sales in 2024, according to RealTrends. Since 2015, Tess and her partner Casey Sternsmith have closed $1.3B+ in total sales, ranking them among the top 5 agents in San Mateo County and the #1 agents in San Mateo for seven consecutive years.

Tess was recognized by Gentry Magazine as one of the Top 10 Agents Under 40 in 2020, and the Sternsmith Group has been nationally recognized on The Leading 100 for the past seven years, celebrating the top-performing real estate teams in the San Francisco Peninsula.

Tess is known for her expertise in off-market listings, pre-market preparation, luxury marketing strategies, and customized property-specific marketing. She leverages Compass’ advanced technology, social media, and Facebook/Instagram Live tours to maximize exposure and deliver top results. With a strong foundation in finance, accounting, and economics, Tess provides data-driven insights that help clients make strategic real estate decisions.

Outside of real estate, Tess is deeply committed to her community. She served as PARCA Auxiliary President (2024–2025), continues on the PARCA Board (2019–2025), volunteers in Hillsborough schools, served on the West Elementary School Site Council, and chairs the Relay for Life for the American Cancer Society.

With 150+ five-star reviews and a reputation for integrity, responsiveness, and personalized service, Tess Salter and the Sternsmith Group provide exceptional guidance, strategic marketing, and unparalleled support for anyone buying or selling in San Mateo County, Burlingame, Hillsborough, and surrounding Peninsula neighborhoods.

About Us

Get to Know Our Team

Get to know our team of real estate experts.

No result found

WORK WITH US

Insightful local knowledge and extensive expertise. We looks forward to earning your family’s trust and leveraging our success for your benefit for generations to come. We looks forward to earning your family’s trust and leveraging our success for your benefit for generations to come.

Contact Us

Follow Us on Instagram